Horizon Europe 2021–2027

Horizon Europe Proposal Review for SMEs and Research Teams

Get feedback on your Part B against the call criteria, with evidence gaps and a prioritised list of revisions. Most Research and Innovation Action (RIA) and Innovation Action (IA) proposals are not rejected on the science — they lose on Impact and Implementation.

Free trial: upload your draft and get a criterion-by-criterion AI evaluation. Sample report: a full worked example on a fictional RIA proposal. Expert review: a GrantGenix advisor reads your draft personally (booked separately).

€93.5B
Total programme budget, 2021–2027
3
Excellence, Impact & Implementation criteria
0–5
Score per criterion, 3.0 threshold to pass
Part B
Technical narrative reviewers score directly

Horizon Europe proposals are assessed by independent expert evaluators against the same three headline criteria, whatever the cluster or call: Excellence, Impact, and Quality & Efficiency of Implementation. Understanding how those criteria are actually weighed — and where reviewers habitually dock points — is the difference between a proposal that reads well internally and one that survives an evaluation summary report.

Who this is for

How Horizon Europe proposals are actually scored

Independent experts score each Horizon Europe proposal against three criteria, each on a 0–5 scale:
CriterionWhat it evaluates
ExcellenceClarity and soundness of the objectives, credibility of the proposed methodology, and ambition — including how convincingly the proposal argues it goes beyond the state of the art.
ImpactThe magnitude and significance of the project's expected outcomes, the quality of measures to maximise impact (dissemination, exploitation, communication), and credibility of the pathway to those outcomes.
Quality and Efficiency of ImplementationCoherence and effectiveness of the work plan, appropriateness of the consortium's combined expertise, and soundness of the management structures and resource allocation.
Where this bites in practice: Each criterion is scored independently and must individually clear a 3.0 threshold, and the summed score across all three criteria must also clear the usual overall threshold of 10 out of 15 — though some calls set a different individual or overall threshold in their specific conditions. A strong Excellence score cannot rescue a proposal that scores below threshold on Impact or Implementation, or that falls short of the call's overall minimum.

Where Horizon Europe proposals lose points

Across RIA, IA and CSA calls, the same patterns recur in Horizon Europe evaluation summary reports:

Impact section reads as generic

Dissemination and exploitation plans repeat boilerplate instead of naming concrete target users, adoption pathways and a credible route to market or policy uptake.

“Beyond the state of the art” is asserted, not shown

The proposal claims novelty without engaging with the specific competing approaches an evaluator in that field would expect to see addressed.

Consortium composition isn't justified

Partner roles and effort (person-months) don't map clearly onto the work packages, leaving reviewers unsure why each partner is included.

Risk management is a formality

A generic risk table with no call-specific mitigation strategies signals the team hasn't stress-tested its own plan.

Get a reviewer-perspective read before you submit GrantGenix's multi-reviewer AI engine is calibrated for Horizon Europe — upload your draft and see what a critical evaluator would flag.
Start Free Trial →

Frequently asked

What's the difference between an RIA and an IA?

A Research and Innovation Action (RIA) funds activities primarily aimed at establishing new knowledge, typically at a lower Technology Readiness Level, and is usually funded at 100% of eligible costs. An Innovation Action (IA) funds activities closer to market, such as prototyping, testing and demonstration, and is typically funded at 70% for for-profit entities (100% for non-profits).

How is the overall Horizon Europe score calculated?

Each criterion score is added together (out of a maximum of 15 across the three criteria), sometimes with Impact weighted more heavily depending on the call. In addition to the 3.0 individual-criterion threshold, the usual overall threshold is 10 out of 15 on the summed score — though some calls set a different individual or overall threshold in their specific conditions, so always check the call text. Proposals that clear every threshold are ranked by total score, and funding is awarded down the ranked list until the call budget is exhausted.

Does GrantGenix replace my proposal writer or consortium's own review?

No. GrantGenix's AI Evaluation gives you a fast, criterion-by-criterion reviewer-perspective read so you can revise before submission. It doesn't write or rewrite your proposal. If you want a GrantGenix advisor to personally review your draft, that's a separate, optional Expert Review booking.

Can GrantGenix evaluate a specific cluster or call topic?

Yes. Upload your draft along with the call identifier and topic text, and the evaluation is calibrated to that call's specific scope and expected impact, on top of the standard Horizon Europe criteria.

What do Horizon Europe evaluators look for in a proposal?

They look for a proposal that answers each criterion directly and credibly: clear, ambitious objectives that go beyond the state of the art (Excellence), specific outcomes with a believable route to impact (Impact), and a coherent work plan, consortium and budget (Quality and efficiency of the implementation). Evaluators score only what is written on the page, so every claim needs evidence and nothing should be left for them to assume.

How do I write a Horizon Europe proposal?

Horizon Europe proposal writing starts from the call text and topic, not from your idea: note the expected outcomes, the scope and any call-specific conditions. Then write Part B against the three evaluation criteria in order, make every objective traceable to work packages, deliverables and milestones, and state who does what in the consortium and why. Leave time for an independent read before submission, ideally by someone who has not seen the draft. Our guide How to write an EU grant proposal: 8 tips goes through each step.

What are the Horizon Europe Excellence, Impact and Implementation criteria?

Excellence covers the clarity and ambition of the objectives, the soundness of the methodology and how far the work goes beyond the state of the art. Impact covers the significance of the expected outcomes, the measures to maximise them (dissemination, exploitation, communication) and the credibility of the pathway. Quality and efficiency of the implementation covers the work plan, the consortium's combined expertise, and the management structures and resources. Each is scored from 0 to 5; the scoring table above shows how the thresholds work.

What are the EU grant evaluation criteria?

They depend on the programme. Horizon Europe RIA and IA proposals are scored on Excellence, Impact and Quality and efficiency of the implementation. EIC Pathfinder uses the same three headings with a separate threshold for each, EIC Accelerator ends with a jury interview, Eurostars checks eligibility first and then scores Excellence, Impact and Quality of Implementation, and Vinnova assesses Potential, Actors and Feasibility. Always confirm against the text of your call.

What are the best tips for an EU grant proposal?

Write to the evaluation criteria, make every claim specific and evidenced, show exactly how the work goes beyond the state of the art, tie each objective to deliverables, justify every partner's role, and check eligibility and thresholds before you start writing. The full list is in How to write an EU grant proposal: 8 tips.

Is there a Horizon Europe proposal template?

Yes. Each call publishes its own Part B template, and the online Part A forms, on the EU Funding & Tenders Portal, and the template differs by action type (for example RIA/IA and CSA). Use the version attached to your call. GrantGenix does not supply the official template; it evaluates your completed draft against the criteria.

See What a Horizon Europe Reviewer Would Flag

Upload your RIA, IA or CSA draft and get a criterion-by-criterion evaluation calibrated to Horizon Europe's Excellence, Impact and Implementation scoring — before your deadline, not after your evaluation summary report.

Request Free Trial → Talk to a Specialist